Won't start...idiot check.

An alchemy of sparks, copper wire and earth

Moderators: User administrators, Moderators

Smosh
Registered user
Posts: 1607
Joined: 30 Aug 2013, 15:40
80-90 Mem No: 12801
Location: Guernsey, 1.9 Watercooled Petrol T25 pop-top

Won't start...idiot check.

Post by Smosh »

Morning all, hoping for some quick early Sunday morning responses...

I cant get my van's engine to turn over.



I've replaced the alternator with a 90amp one. The previous had a plug connector and new is round terminals.



I have removed the alt to junction box cable and gone straight to starter.



I have a new positive connection from B+ to starter solenoid. the existing start solenoid to battery and solenoid to junction box look ok.



I am getting 12+ volts at the start solenoid, B+ post and junction box.



I havent added nor (I think) removed any earths. There is one from gearbox to chassis and battery to chassis.

Note: It used to start (slow turnover and crap battery) before I made these changes.



Any suggestions?
1984 Voltswagen 25 Pop-Top (No idea what type!?) 1.9 W/C Petrol based in Guernsey, C.I.

MidLifeCrisis
Registered user
Posts: 566
Joined: 20 Nov 2011, 19:07
80-90 Mem No: 10519
Location: Bagshot, Surrey

Re: Won't start...idiot check.

Post by MidLifeCrisis »

None of those changes you made should effect the ability to turn over the engine (but they may stop it starting up)
If your starter is not working at all then I'd check that
A) you have 12v at the thick wire going to the starter
B) you have 12v at the thin wire going to the starter when the ignition key is turned to start position
C) the starter external case has continuity to ground
1987 Westfalia Van, Petrol 2.0 AGG

Smosh
Registered user
Posts: 1607
Joined: 30 Aug 2013, 15:40
80-90 Mem No: 12801
Location: Guernsey, 1.9 Watercooled Petrol T25 pop-top

Re: Won't start...idiot check.

Post by Smosh »

MidLifeCrisis wrote:None of those changes you made should effect the ability to turn over the engine (but they may stop it starting up)
If your starter is not working at all then I'd check that
A) you have 12v at the thick wire going to the starter
B) you have 12v at the thin wire going to the starter when the ignition key is turned to start position
C) the starter external case has continuity to ground


How do I check 'C) the starter external case has continuity to ground' is there a good point to clip a jump lead onto?
1984 Voltswagen 25 Pop-Top (No idea what type!?) 1.9 W/C Petrol based in Guernsey, C.I.

Smosh
Registered user
Posts: 1607
Joined: 30 Aug 2013, 15:40
80-90 Mem No: 12801
Location: Guernsey, 1.9 Watercooled Petrol T25 pop-top

Re: Won't start...idiot check.

Post by Smosh »

A) Yes
B) Yes
C) Not sure

I have a drop in the power levels at about 0.01v per second when the ignition is on.

I have power going to trigger wire.
1984 Voltswagen 25 Pop-Top (No idea what type!?) 1.9 W/C Petrol based in Guernsey, C.I.

Smosh
Registered user
Posts: 1607
Joined: 30 Aug 2013, 15:40
80-90 Mem No: 12801
Location: Guernsey, 1.9 Watercooled Petrol T25 pop-top

Re: Won't start...idiot check.

Post by Smosh »

okay. So the problem seems to be with the run from the battery to the starter. I say this because;

With everything hooked up, a multimeter from negative to earth reads 12.5v; positive to earth reads 0.07.

with the battery/starter cable replaced with jump leads the voltage switches; 0.07 negative; 12.5v positive.

This to me suggests a problem with the cable (maybe trapped and earthing on the fuel tank i changed).

However, with the cable temporarily replaced by jump leads, the van still didnt spring to life... :?
1984 Voltswagen 25 Pop-Top (No idea what type!?) 1.9 W/C Petrol based in Guernsey, C.I.

Smosh
Registered user
Posts: 1607
Joined: 30 Aug 2013, 15:40
80-90 Mem No: 12801
Location: Guernsey, 1.9 Watercooled Petrol T25 pop-top

Re: Won't start...idiot check.

Post by Smosh »

Okay, so I maybe wrong. It looks like all my new wiring is fine and I have a short on the way to the dash. If I remove that cable from the battery my positive and negative work the right way around.

Any suggestions on how to locate the area at fault?
1984 Voltswagen 25 Pop-Top (No idea what type!?) 1.9 W/C Petrol based in Guernsey, C.I.

User avatar
BOXY
Registered user
Posts: 1101
Joined: 21 Feb 2009, 15:37
80-90 Mem No: 8826
Location: Sunny SouthWest

Re: Won't start...idiot check.

Post by BOXY »

With everything hooked up, a multimeter from negative to earth reads 12.5v; positive to earth reads 0.07.

with the battery/starter cable replaced with jump leads the voltage switches; 0.07 negative; 12.5v positive.

How are you checking the voltage? The flow of electricity from the battery can only go from positive to negative (earth). If you had a short from the positive terminal to earth you would either be blowing a fuse or melting the insulation of the wiring.
2ltr Aircooled CU with twin Solex's & originally a 009 dizzie, but now back to standard.

Smosh
Registered user
Posts: 1607
Joined: 30 Aug 2013, 15:40
80-90 Mem No: 12801
Location: Guernsey, 1.9 Watercooled Petrol T25 pop-top

Re: Won't start...idiot check.

Post by Smosh »

Sorry, I must be explaining what I did badly and jumping to conclusions! Is this clearer?

Step one
So with everything connected as I thought it should be on a freshly charged battery:

Probed the multimeter between the +ve of the battery and the bodywork = 0v
probed the multimeter between the -ve of the battery and the bodywork = 12v

Step two
removed the feed to the dash

Probed the multimeter between the +ve of the battery and the bodywork = 12v
probed the multimeter between the -ve of the battery and the bodywork = 0v

Problem
Not a feckin' clue... short somewhere?

Solution

Not a feckin' clue... Beg for help on the forum :lol:
1984 Voltswagen 25 Pop-Top (No idea what type!?) 1.9 W/C Petrol based in Guernsey, C.I.

Ralf85
Registered user
Posts: 4447
Joined: 13 Jan 2010, 12:42
80-90 Mem No: 4418
Location: West London - 1985 westie pop top, LHD, 1900 DF engine

Re: Won't start...idiot check.

Post by Ralf85 »

Knackered ignition switch?

User avatar
Smiffo
Registered user
Posts: 2313
Joined: 20 May 2014, 12:09
80-90 Mem No: 15151
Location: Bristol

Re: Won't start...idiot check.

Post by Smiffo »

Smosh wrote:Sorry, I must be explaining what I did badly and jumping to conclusions! Is this clearer?

Step one
So with everything connected as I thought it should be on a freshly charged battery:

Probed the multimeter between the +ve of the battery and the bodywork = 0v
probed the multimeter between the -ve of the battery and the bodywork = 12v

Step two
removed the feed to the dash

Probed the multimeter between the +ve of the battery and the bodywork = 12v
probed the multimeter between the -ve of the battery and the bodywork = 0v

Problem
Not a feckin' clue... short somewhere?

Solution

Not a feckin' clue... Beg for help on the forum :lol:

Negative side of battery to bodywork = 12v?

Jeepers mate, is that with key in and turned on, or with key out of ignition, or with jey in and trying to start the engine?
I am struggling to picture exactly what is going on there.
What is resistance of -ve of battery to body?
'89 1.9 DG

“Some people die at 25 years old, and are buried at 75 yrs old” ~ Benjamin Franklin.

Smosh
Registered user
Posts: 1607
Joined: 30 Aug 2013, 15:40
80-90 Mem No: 12801
Location: Guernsey, 1.9 Watercooled Petrol T25 pop-top

Re: Won't start...idiot check.

Post by Smosh »

Yep! -ve of Batt. to bodywork. I believe that was with the ignition off! I didnt check resistance? :oops:

As a side note I recently changed the fuel tank (havent ran it since) so could have trapped/ damaged the dash feed at some point?
1984 Voltswagen 25 Pop-Top (No idea what type!?) 1.9 W/C Petrol based in Guernsey, C.I.

User avatar
CovKid
Trader
Posts: 8411
Joined: 30 Apr 2006, 13:19
80-90 Mem No: 3529
Location: Ralph - Coventry (Retired)
Contact:

Re: Won't start...idiot check.

Post by CovKid »

With battery disconnected, check EVERYTHING you've done - twice, in turn. Something somewhere isn't right. You'll no doubt kick yourself when you spot it.
Roller paint your camper at home: http://roller.epizy.com/55554/" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false; for MP4 download.

User avatar
Smiffo
Registered user
Posts: 2313
Joined: 20 May 2014, 12:09
80-90 Mem No: 15151
Location: Bristol

Re: Won't start...idiot check.

Post by Smiffo »

Smosh wrote:Yep! -ve of Batt. to bodywork. I believe that was with the ignition off! I didnt check resistance? :oops:

As a side note I recently changed the fuel tank (havent ran it since) so could have trapped/ damaged the dash feed at some point?

Tell me to sod off if this sounds stupid, but you have made sure that the neg post on the battery goes to the earth strap the the body?
Sounds like you have battery in the wrong way round to me
'89 1.9 DG

“Some people die at 25 years old, and are buried at 75 yrs old” ~ Benjamin Franklin.

Smosh
Registered user
Posts: 1607
Joined: 30 Aug 2013, 15:40
80-90 Mem No: 12801
Location: Guernsey, 1.9 Watercooled Petrol T25 pop-top

Re: Won't start...idiot check.

Post by Smosh »

Smiffo wrote:
Smosh wrote:Yep! -ve of Batt. to bodywork. I believe that was with the ignition off! I didnt check resistance? :oops:

As a side note I recently changed the fuel tank (havent ran it since) so could have trapped/ damaged the dash feed at some point?

Tell me to sod off if this sounds stupid, but you have made sure that the neg post on the battery goes to the earth strap the the body?
Sounds like you have battery in the wrong way round to me

Not too stupid a thing to ask. I did have to check that!

CovKid wrote:TOPIC REVIEW: WON'T START...IDIOT CHECK.

I'm sure it is something stupid. But I cannot find it. The thing that is throwing me is that it seems to go to "pooh" when I connect the feed to the dash. something I haven't actually messed with.
1984 Voltswagen 25 Pop-Top (No idea what type!?) 1.9 W/C Petrol based in Guernsey, C.I.

User avatar
BOXY
Registered user
Posts: 1101
Joined: 21 Feb 2009, 15:37
80-90 Mem No: 8826
Location: Sunny SouthWest

Re: Won't start...idiot check.

Post by BOXY »

As Covkid said, disconnect the battery & the leisure battery if you've got one.
Put the multimeter set to DC across the battery terminals and see what voltage you've got from the battery or batteries.
I'm struggling to see how you can be getting +12v between the negative on the battery and the earth. Are you sure you've got the probes on the multimeter plugged in to the right sockets?
2ltr Aircooled CU with twin Solex's & originally a 009 dizzie, but now back to standard.

Post Reply