Page 1 of 3

What do you reckon to this winch ? worth it ?

Posted: 16 Nov 2010, 12:36
by John Potter
on ebay, £340 + p&p - what do you reckon... 12v, 12500lbs, 30m of 11mm 12 strand synthetic rope etc ?

Winch Picture.jpg

I could buy it for yule present for better half.. ...

Re: What do you reckon to this winch ? worth it ?

Posted: 16 Nov 2010, 12:41
by silverbullet
Looks very familiar... just let me do a headstand in front of the PC...
Jeds winch installation.jpg

Re: What do you reckon to this winch ? worth it ?

Posted: 16 Nov 2010, 13:03
by Aidan
John Potter wrote:on ebay, £340 + p&p - what do you reckon... 12v, 12500lbs, 30m of 11mm 12 strand synthetic rope etc ?

Winch Picture.jpg

I could buy it for yule present for better half.. ...

I'd wait till your gearbox is stripped iiwy

Re: What do you reckon to this winch ? worth it ?

Posted: 16 Nov 2010, 13:05
by syncroand101
I reckon anyone with a winch fitted is more likely to get stuck..

Re: What do you reckon to this winch ? worth it ?

Posted: 16 Nov 2010, 13:46
by John Potter
Aidan wrote:
John Potter wrote:on ebay, £340 + p&p - what do you reckon... 12v, 12500lbs, 30m of 11mm 12 strand synthetic rope etc ?

Winch Picture.jpg

I could buy it for yule present for better half.. ...

I'd wait till your gearbox is stripped iiwy

She's paying for that as my Xmas present. Told her what good value you were Aidan.....may have forgotten to mention the actual number though

Re: What do you reckon to this winch ? worth it ?

Posted: 16 Nov 2010, 15:22
by syncropaddy
Or this one ....

http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Recovery-Winch-12 ... 43a3168a17

There is loads of them ...

Re: What do you reckon to this winch ? worth it ?

Posted: 16 Nov 2010, 16:15
by silverbullet
If...I was in the market for a winch (big if) and had a syncro with PAS, I would give serious consideration to the likes of a Milemarker hydraulic winch.
Lighter and more powerful than an electric, will work all day at full load until you run out of fuel, no wiring to fuse/melt/short out/flood. To be found on the back of recovery trucks across the land...

Re: What do you reckon to this winch ? worth it ?

Posted: 16 Nov 2010, 16:46
by syncropaddy
silverbullet wrote:If...I was in the market for a winch (big if) and had a syncro with PAS, I would give serious consideration to the likes of a Milemarker hydraulic winch.
Lighter and more powerful than an electric, will work all day at full load until you run out of fuel, no wiring to fuse/melt/short out/flood. To be found on the back of recovery trucks across the land...

But not too good if your engine has drowned out

Re: What do you reckon to this winch ? worth it ?

Posted: 16 Nov 2010, 17:16
by v-lux
Use an electric hydraulic pump? no electrics on the winch to drown, and power even if you have killed the engine?

Re: What do you reckon to this winch ? worth it ?

Posted: 16 Nov 2010, 17:18
by silverbullet
There's a downside to either system, but...if your engine's drowned then there won't be any charging available for your very rapidly draining battery whatever.
Then you're up the shizer and no mistake.

Re: What do you reckon to this winch ? worth it ?

Posted: 16 Nov 2010, 17:25
by jed the spread
Leisure battery....

jed

Re: What do you reckon to this winch ? worth it ?

Posted: 16 Nov 2010, 17:32
by jed the spread
John Potter wrote:on ebay, £340 + p&p - what do you reckon... 12v, 12500lbs, 30m of 11mm 12 strand synthetic rope etc ?

Winch Picture.jpg

I could buy it for yule present for better half.. ...


I have one, but with a Superwinch plasma rope to be fitted. I havnt used it in anger yet so cant comment constructively on any winch on a van I have actually been in control of and dont have anything to compare it to that I have actually used to tow a Syncro out with. Pete has one that seems to work well and he has towed me a few times in various conditions with the desired results.

jed

Re: What do you reckon to this winch ? worth it ?

Posted: 16 Nov 2010, 18:57
by syncrodoug

Re: What do you reckon to this winch ? worth it ?

Posted: 16 Nov 2010, 22:10
by silverbullet
Fluid power is the way forward...when did you ever see an all-electric HIAB?

Re: What do you reckon to this winch ? worth it ?

Posted: 17 Nov 2010, 09:16
by v-lux
Question is.. Do you really need a winch?

First I'd make sure i had one of these:
Image

Some of these:

Image

and one of these:

Image

Only then would i consider getting a winch, and even then, You're probably better off with one of these:

Image

You can attach one of those to wherever you want on the van, rather than just the front.