Page 1 of 1

Best gearbox oil? (SPaddy you are excused!)

Posted: 23 Sep 2010, 22:35
by KarlT
I know its been talked about & there is alittle on WIKI from a few years back but what's presently thought to be the best Front & Rear box oils to go for.
Is it GL4 front-diff & GL5 Gearbox, or the other way round, I can't remember!

Re: Best gearbox oil? (SPaddy you are excused!)

Posted: 24 Sep 2010, 02:10
by dave friday
gl5 front diff ... gl4 w75 90 gear box... sorry a bit pist, red wine very cheap here!!

Re: Best gearbox oil? (SPaddy you are excused!)

Posted: 24 Sep 2010, 06:05
by axeman
I used carplan (thats the brand) fully synthetic 75/90 gl4/gl5 in both front and rear boxes

Neil

Re: Best gearbox oil? (SPaddy you are excused!)

Posted: 24 Sep 2010, 06:23
by syncrosimon
axeman wrote:I used carplan (thats the brand) fully synthetic 75/90 gl4/gl5 in both front and rear boxes

Neil

So do I!

Re: Best gearbox oil? (SPaddy you are excused!)

Posted: 24 Sep 2010, 06:31
by jed the spread
I put in what Aiden tells me to

jed

Re: Best gearbox oil? (SPaddy you are excused!)

Posted: 24 Sep 2010, 10:43
by syncropaddy
jed the spread wrote:I put in what Aiden tells me to

jed

So did I!!!

In my white van I use what VW put in!

Im off now .....

Re: Best gearbox oil? (SPaddy you are excused!)

Posted: 26 Sep 2010, 11:29
by KarlT
axeman wrote:I used carplan (thats the brand) fully synthetic 75/90 gl4/gl5 in both front and rear boxes

Neil

Do you mean GL4/GL5 (doesn't matter which) in both boxes?

Re: Best gearbox oil? (SPaddy you are excused!)

Posted: 26 Sep 2010, 11:37
by axeman
the spec of the oil is GL4/5 which means as i understand it, it is suitable for bith gl4 spec and gl5. i confirmed this with adian before i bought the oil and he said it was all good to use. i used the same oil in both boxes.

neil

Re: Best gearbox oil? (SPaddy you are excused!)

Posted: 26 Sep 2010, 11:40
by syncrosimon
I use it in both, last 3000 miles.
Image
Saves having two bottles of oil.

Re: Best gearbox oil? (SPaddy you are excused!)

Posted: 26 Sep 2010, 11:57
by syncropaddy
GL4 and GL5 are different and you cant use one of them in both gearbox and front diff as it corrodes bronze synchromesh rings or something. Its GL4 for the box and GL5/GL4 for the front diff. Dont know about dual spec stuff though but if Aidan say its ok then it is. We can sue him later

Re: Best gearbox oil? (SPaddy you are excused!)

Posted: 26 Sep 2010, 15:30
by syncrosimon
This gl/4 gl/5 thing is a myth that does not apply to synthetic modern oils.

(i hope)

Re: Best gearbox oil? (SPaddy you are excused!)

Posted: 26 Sep 2010, 16:35
by toomanytoys
some GL5 only oils have the nasty addative that will corrode the "yellow metal" parts.. but this usually happens above 100 deg C... (and surprisingly these boxes do see that temperature on a run)

Most dual rated oils ie GL4/5 are ok.. but its worth getting confimation from the manufacturer.. I know the Millers and Fuchs ones are ok (as Aidan checked up on these) and I would assume Comma SX 75/90 is too as its been in my caravelle for the last 10 years and 200k km.... (2 changes )

Re: Best gearbox oil? (SPaddy you are excused!)

Posted: 26 Sep 2010, 17:59
by syncropaddy
I cant imagine it would make any difference to all you guys cuz you dont have the oil in your boxes long enough .............

Re: Best gearbox oil? (SPaddy you are excused!)

Posted: 26 Sep 2010, 19:50
by toomanytoys
syncropaddy wrote:I cant imagine it would make any difference to all you guys cuz you dont have the oil in your boxes long enough .............