PEET wrote:Why are these central lock kits slow and not likethe positive click newer ones? R upgrades possible? Mind you the centarl locking match the electric windows...

You really want to know? Okay then...
The VW ones are slow because of the way they are inside, no you can't really speed them up (though fitting super fast motors might be a pointless help). Internally they have a worm drive off the motor that turns a big wheel through half a turn useing low gearing - A pin on the wheel pushes the arm in and out but its aloud to move freely once the rest point has been reached at the end of the 1/2 revolution. This is needed as the worm drive gearbox can't be driven backwards from its output so the piston can't turn the motor - if it didn't disconect the motor you wouldn't be able to manually move the pistor and therefore couldn't unlock the door manually! The big wheel also controls when the motor should run by contacts underneath it. A sliding contact on the side of the piston (on all motors but only actully doing something on cab door motors) controls wether the motors should run in or out so no external controls are needed, you just wire all motors together. The motors always run in the same direction aswell so no seperate control is needed there eather. Because of this the wires needed are...
1) a wire to make the actuator extend (always +ve)
2) a wire to make it contract (always +ve)
Each of the above wires lets the motor run for 180° of the big wheel, one wire alows the motor to run in the the 0-180° region, the other the 180°-360° region, asuming the wire controling that segment is live (that depends on the position of the pistons on the cab doors, as all cab door pistons move together only 1 half of the wheel will be live at once so the motors stop when the dead side of the wheel is reached)
3) an earth (that never changes as the motor always turns the same way)
4) wire is to power the front motors and make them switch the motors on. (and control the other motors)
As the gearing is low its very strong and could damage the motor/geartrain if the actuator jammed, to cure this there is a spring in the piston leaver which alows the big wheel to turn even if the piston can't move, the spring compresses and takes up the movement. You'll hear a bang noise if this happens but its probubly not the fault of the actuator, more the door lock itself and damages nothing. The only way I can see these actuators comming to harm under their own power is if the big wheel jammed half way through its cycle and it left the motor on whilst stalled, it'd burn it out. That would probubly only happen if there was bad corrosion inside the actuator though so it'd be knackered anyway. In reality if the corosion was that bad the actuator would break by poor contacts first and just seaze up afterwards through lack of use makeing repair harder.
Still with me? The "other" type...
Never had a look inside the other style actuator but looking at the shape of it and feal of it I'd say theres a motor perpendicular to the piston driving it by a less extremely geared (faster) rack and pinion, perminantly ingaged. The geartrain can be moved manually and the motor spinns one way to go in and the other way to go out. If for some resion the actuator is jammed the motor will stall, as its only powered for about a second it won't care too much. You need the extra wire on these motors because the wires do these functions...
1) Perminant live feed for switch
2) switch output - tells controler to spin motor one way
3) switch output - tells controler to go other way
4) Motor winding +ve*
5) Motor winding -ve*
* field direction varies acording to which direction motor needs to move.
actuators that control other doors need all 5 wires, responding motors only need wires 4 and 5.
(For changing genuine VW actuators to these you'd need to loose the seperate earth wires and add the 2 switching wires, in practise that'd mean converting the earth into a swithing wire and adding 1 extra wire.)
When the control box revies a signal from one of the switch wires it powers the motors in the required direction - you'll hear a loud click as the motors quickly shunt the piston to its limits and another click soon after as the motors shut down again when the controlers pulse finishes. The control box needed is probubly some relays and a timer.
As for upgrading and which is best? Don't think there is a best, they are both different ways of doing the same job with simular results. The VW ones seem to break once every 15-20 years but I bet the cheep crap ones from China will have their faults in that timespan and aren't serviceable unlike the proper VW ones. Personly I like the steady wering noise of the VW ones and like OEM stuff (they would please me more knowing its "right", and ofcourse working perfectly!(I cry if things aren't working right, unless it has a querky charm that you can lern with the right techneque)), though a part of me wishes I didn't care so much, I think its a form of OCD! One of the many things that make me a weardo. Still, in some way or another, there you go - hopefully not too badly explained but with unreadable spelling

.