Page 1 of 1

Ball joint stucknin the knuckle

Posted: 23 Mar 2023, 19:44
by pleasestartnow
So I started tackling the one of the upper ball joints and it was all going well until it came to getting the ball joint out of the knuckle. No budging, absolute belting it with hammer for the last 40mins and no movement. Took the grinder to the top on the joint and noe the bottom part is stuck. Am I right in saying the part in the knuckle itself isn't threaded? Any ideas on what to try next to get it out, barring taking the whole thing apart which I am trying to avoid for now?

Re: Ball joint stucknin the knuckle

Posted: 23 Mar 2023, 21:08
by maxstu
Photos always help.....if you can post them?

Re: Ball joint stucknin the knuckle

Posted: 23 Mar 2023, 21:23
by pleasestartnow
Whoops, sorry I thought I had included these

ImageImageImage

Re: Ball joint stucknin the knuckle

Posted: 23 Mar 2023, 21:59
by maxstu
Put the nut back on and hit the face of the nut upwards. The bit you are hitting is tapered? Or a G clamp forcing thread upwards using a socket over the top
Get a plumbers torch on it and give it some heat.

Re: Ball joint stucknin the knuckle

Posted: 23 Mar 2023, 22:03
by pleasestartnow
Didn't think of the G-clamp, good idea I will give that a go and see. Is it tapered? That would make sense now, I'm some dope 😅

Re: Ball joint stucknin the knuckle

Posted: 23 Mar 2023, 22:27
by maxstu
:rofl. Im pretty certain it is slightly tapered.
Just give it a spray of Plusgas. Have a cuppa. Then give it a bash upwards.

Re: Ball joint stucknin the knuckle

Posted: 25 Mar 2023, 09:14
by maxstu
So, what happened?

I have a spare Moog lower ball joint in garage. It is ever so slightly tapered.

I bet that one will knock upwards with a swift wallop.

Re: Ball joint stucknin the knuckle

Posted: 25 Mar 2023, 15:14
by pleasestartnow
Ha you beat me to it, I literally just finished sorting it about 20 mins ago.

Got the g-clamp and large socket head on it and gave it a wack and eventually up she popped. You were spot on with it being tapered. I won't tell you how long I spent hammering it the wrong way on Thursday night haha. It was in well tight though as I started bending the handles on the g-clamp trying to force it out.

Thank you so much as I would never have thought of putting a large socket head over it to get it out like. I will just go and buy the right tool for the remaining one i say.
Image

Re: Ball joint stucknin the knuckle

Posted: 25 Mar 2023, 15:34
by maxstu
Well done! :ok

Depending how much is stripped from the other side....
Wheel off. Trolley jack about an inch under control arm. Support disc and caliper with wire or bungee cables to stop it falling to one side and damaging brake line.
Compress control arm against suspension spring with trolley jack. Remove nut. Drop trolley jack so it still about an inch from control arm (to catch control arm) and with two large hammers simultaneously bash knuckle either side of upper ball joint.

Worked for me.

Re: Ball joint stucknin the knuckle

Posted: 25 Mar 2023, 16:03
by pleasestartnow
Ya i must do the lower ball joints as well at some point over Easter and i might change the brake discs as well as there is pitting around the edges of the disc and the centre part so when i take off the knuckle it will hopefully go a lot smoother. Next job i suppose is to get someone to press in/out the lower ball joints for me. 

Re: Ball joint stucknin the knuckle

Posted: 25 Mar 2023, 16:59
by maxstu
What year is your camper or van?

I replaced the lower ball joint without using a press.

Re: Ball joint stucknin the knuckle

Posted: 25 Mar 2023, 17:31
by maxstu
Knocking out is fun and rewarding. Getting new one in is not that easy. But l did it with a blunted cold chisel and club hammer.

Bag it and put lower ball joint in freezer for a couple of days.

Clamp up the knuckle in a large vice. Or a pal hold it. :shock: Give the backside a mighty whack with a small sledgehammer or large club hammer, and grin from ear to ear as it flies out.
Pick up yer mate's front teeth.. :run

Image

Thoroughly clean area around and inside hole

before attempting the next bit.

Image

The ball joint has a skirt with a cut away bit. This goes facing the upright of the knuckle. Nearest in photo.

Image

Warm up the area and lubricate. Using a cold chisel with the sharp tip removed I then knocked the new ball joint all the way home with a series of small taps around the skirt until correctly set...then heavier wallops to move it down until fully seated.

Image

Note small cut out in ball joint and scribed mark line on knuckle to aid alignment

Image

Re: Ball joint stucknin the knuckle

Posted: 25 Mar 2023, 18:36
by pleasestartnow
Its 1990, 1.9 straight diesel. Ya I saw a previous post where someone said the same about banging it in the freezer. I'm half thinking of trying that alright, I am heading away on Thursday till Sunday so I could bang them into the freezer then and could give it a go Monday then sher.

Re: Ball joint stucknin the knuckle

Posted: 26 Mar 2023, 21:37
by mioba
And use antiseize when refittings. Makes it all easier next time.

Re: Ball joint stucknin the knuckle

Posted: 07 Apr 2023, 17:10
by pleasestartnow
Image

Quick update here folks, ye might have seen the other thread where I had issues with the tie rod but now finally on a Friday evening I have all 3 ball joints done and a new tie rod. The knuckle is back in position. It feels way way tighter than before, like previously when I took off the top ball joint the knuckle fell outward whereas now it stays in position unless physically moved.

Next step is to get on the new disc, new bearings,old caliper and old carriage and new pads. Do I need a new spacer ring I wonder or is the old one fine.