Page 3 of 4

Re: Replacing westy fluorescent tube with LED tube

Posted: 13 Feb 2014, 22:49
by AdrianC
MattBW wrote:but the power consumption is so low, great. :)

I'm not sure that a 3-4w (~0.3A) saving's that significant in the grand scheme of things.

Re: Replacing westy fluorescent tube with LED tube

Posted: 15 Feb 2014, 17:00
by trucker
My cheapo one is fitted.

Before
Image

After
Image

Very pleased, they are a little cold but much,much brighter 8)

Re: Replacing westy fluorescent tube with LED tube

Posted: 15 Feb 2014, 17:53
by California Dreamin
I like that....yes a little white and you can see the individual LEDS but it's not bad at all...those 50:50's are very bright...a piece of tracing paper (grease proof oven paper) might diffuse and warm things a slightly.

Martin

Re: Replacing westy fluorescent tube with LED tube

Posted: 15 Feb 2014, 18:50
by trucker
To be honest the individual leds are probably more pronounced than the camera shows. I'm still pleased but I'll give the grease proof paper a go later as you suggest

Re: Replacing westy fluorescent tube with LED tube

Posted: 15 Feb 2014, 18:54
by AdrianC
trucker wrote:Very pleased... much,much brighter 8)

Have to admit, I don't think I ever felt ours needed to be brighter. One striplight on was usually fine, even to read by.

Re: Replacing westy fluorescent tube with LED tube

Posted: 15 Feb 2014, 19:44
by trucker
AdrianC wrote:
trucker wrote:Very pleased... much,much brighter 8)

Have to admit, I don't think I ever felt ours needed to be brighter. One striplight on was usually fine, even to read by.

I think the flourescents in ours were particularly yellow and dim compared to most

Re: Replacing westy fluorescent tube with LED tube

Posted: 15 Feb 2014, 20:42
by Oldiebut goodie
You can diffuse the light from leds a little by roughening the lens with sandpaper.

Replacing westy fluorescent tube with LED tube

Posted: 17 Feb 2014, 21:20
by MattBW
AdrianC wrote:
MattBW wrote:but the power consumption is so low, great. :)

I'm not sure that a 3-4w (~0.3A) saving's that significant in the grand scheme of things.

Lol I guess not but every little counts ;-) and it was a straight swap ready made led tube no mods required :)

Re: Replacing westy fluorescent tube with LED tube

Posted: 17 Feb 2014, 21:53
by danmetallic
trucker wrote:My cheapo one is fitted.

Before
Image

After
Image

Very pleased, they are a little cold but much,much brighter 8)

Liking how yours turned out a lot, good job!

Re: Replacing westy fluorescent tube with LED tube

Posted: 18 Feb 2014, 17:01
by simoncummins
danmetallic That bulb you fitted is that the one in the link you put on back on page one as i may be being daft but cant find where its for 12v or 240v for that matter.

Re: Replacing westy fluorescent tube with LED tube

Posted: 18 Feb 2014, 19:42
by danmetallic
simoncummins wrote:danmetallic That bulb you fitted is that the one in the link you put on back on page one as i may be being daft but cant find where its for 12v or 240v for that matter.

Well they're a boat light supplier and there's the "Voltage range 10 - 30 volts DC"

That's what I went on anyway ;-)

Re: Replacing westy fluorescent tube with LED tube

Posted: 27 Feb 2014, 21:31
by ninja.turtle007
With a fluorescent tube not working and having some off cuts of led ribbon in warm white I cobbled together this.

Image

It is very crude but is didn't cost anything to make. The light is actually rather good in terms colour, spread and brightness. It is less white than it looks in the pics. You can obviously see the LED's through the diffuser. I've not committed yet as I haven't modified the actual light unit.

Image

Image

Image

Re: Replacing westy fluorescent tube with LED tube

Posted: 27 Feb 2014, 21:57
by danmetallic
Not bad at all!

Re: Replacing westy fluorescent tube with LED tube

Posted: 27 Feb 2014, 22:45
by Adeybruce
I popped one of the £25 LED tubes in, very happy with the results. Whilst I'd like to get all 3 done, it's quite a lot of money that I'm not sure I need to spend. I think in most circumstances just one tube switched on is good enough.

Re: Replacing westy fluorescent tube with LED tube

Posted: 28 Feb 2014, 08:39
by AdrianC
Was the multimeter pic with the battery charging (engine running/hookup), or just 12v?

0.22A @ 12v = 2.6W
0.22A @ 14v = 3.1W

Not bad.