Page 2 of 3

Re: So you reckon EGR is good?

Posted: 17 Mar 2012, 20:51
by lloydy
It's the silver looking flexi pipe that attaches to the manifold isn't it? From what dave said, the Blanking plate will be fitted and that flexi pipe fitted back over. I'm sure that's what was said, correct me if I'm wrong of course?

Re: So you reckon EGR is good?

Posted: 17 Mar 2012, 20:51
by guzzi
syncroandy wrote:
lloydy wrote:I'm having the blanking plate fitted, but all the EGR stuff left in place. It'll look like I still have it then.
?


MOT requirment?

Re: So you reckon EGR is good?

Posted: 17 Mar 2012, 20:52
by Cableguy
syncropaddy wrote:
southernsparky wrote:Only recently weighed out £900 for a pair of trick heads for my boat anchor.
Money down the pan. They're still sitting in the boxes they came back in from the engineers.
Will have to stick them on eBay, but doubt I'll get even half that figure back.

Am I the only one still trying to work out exactly What the blithering heck this post has to do with anything? Or have you all given up?

Sorry, a bit random :-)
Related to my boring ramblings on the alternate engine forum
:P

Re: So you reckon EGR is good?

Posted: 17 Mar 2012, 20:57
by syncroandy
lloydy wrote:It's the silver looking flexi pipe that attaches to the manifold isn't it? From what dave said, the Blanking plate will be fitted and that flexi pipe fitted back over. I'm sure that's what was said, correct me if I'm wrong of course?

Sure, but why ? You're under no obligation to keep it. Maybe in some less enlightened countries, but not in GB, yet.

Re: So you reckon EGR is good?

Posted: 17 Mar 2012, 21:01
by max and caddy
No MOT reqeerment at present is correct...but cats are now in theory at least. just get rid of it all i say.

Re: So you reckon EGR is good?

Posted: 17 Mar 2012, 21:09
by lloydy
syncroandy wrote:
lloydy wrote:It's the silver looking flexi pipe that attaches to the manifold isn't it? From what dave said, the Blanking plate will be fitted and that flexi pipe fitted back over. I'm sure that's what was said, correct me if I'm wrong of course?

Sure, but why ? You're under no obligation to keep it. Maybe in some less enlightened countries, but not in GB, yet.
Doesn't really matter does it? Both ways do the same job.
On tHis subject, westyventures on thesamba pointed me towards this thread. http://forums.tdiclub.com/showthread.php?t=90485" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
Crankcase breather filter, stops the dampness that enables the soot from EGR to settle. Not cheap though!

Re: So you reckon EGR is good?

Posted: 17 Mar 2012, 21:30
by syncroandy
No it doesn't matter, just takes up a bit of space. Yes the Mann Provent looks good doesn't it, but the price has put me off. A cheaper alternative is the oil separator VW and Audi fitted to some vehicles inline with the breather pipe going from block to head. I've been keeping my eye open when I visit the local breakers but not found one yet.

Re: So you reckon EGR is good?

Posted: 17 Mar 2012, 21:35
by lloydy
syncroandy wrote:A cheaper alternative is the oil separator VW and Audi fitted to some vehicles inline with the breather pipe going from block to head. I've been keeping my eye open when I visit the local breakers but not found one yet.
Do you know what engine, model cars they were fitted to?

Re: So you reckon EGR is good?

Posted: 17 Mar 2012, 21:53
by syncroandy
lloydy wrote:
syncroandy wrote:A cheaper alternative is the oil separator VW and Audi fitted to some vehicles inline with the breather pipe going from block to head. I've been keeping my eye open when I visit the local breakers but not found one yet.
Do you know what engine, model cars they were fitted to?

Various, including Passat 3B and Audi A4 with later 90/110bhp TDi's. eg. in ETOS for 98 Passat the page is 103-85. Oil separators are fitted to quite a few vehicles, maybe some could be adapted to suit, but it'd be easier to get the one designed for 'our' engines. I'll find one, just need to be patient..

Re: So you reckon EGR is good?

Posted: 17 Mar 2012, 22:01
by lloydy
found a part number on vagcat
052103495
says its 17.35 euros

Re: So you reckon EGR is good?

Posted: 17 Mar 2012, 22:17
by syncroandy
Yes, thats the one, the correct pipes may also be needed to hook it up. Not sure you could get away with just cutting into the regular single breather pipe to insert the separator. I'm hoping to find a complete 'kit' off a scrapper.

Re: So you reckon EGR is good?

Posted: 17 Mar 2012, 22:22
by jed the spread
I know a couple of people might find all this annoying but I find all this info and interest in recent trend towards AFN engine installs really interesting. I know no two are the same right now but its awesome that there is a constant flow of new things to think about, you just dont get that anywhere else at the moment.

jed

Re: So you reckon EGR is good?

Posted: 17 Mar 2012, 22:24
by lloydy
syncroandy wrote:Yes, thats the one, the correct pipes may also be needed to hook it up. Not sure you could get away with just cutting into the regular single breather pipe to insert the separator. I'm hoping to find a complete 'kit' off a scrapper.
You never know, there could be one on mine :lol:

Re: So you reckon EGR is good?

Posted: 17 Mar 2012, 22:27
by lloydy
jed the spread wrote:I know a couple of people might find all this annoying but I find all this info and interest in recent trend towards AFN engine installs really interesting. I know no two are the same right now but its awesome that there is a constant flow of new things to think about, you just dont get that anywhere else at the moment.

jed
it's all good isnt it, lots of new info all the time

Re: So you reckon EGR is good?

Posted: 17 Mar 2012, 22:33
by jed the spread
lloydy wrote:
jed the spread wrote:I know a couple of people might find all this annoying but I find all this info and interest in recent trend towards AFN engine installs really interesting. I know no two are the same right now but its awesome that there is a constant flow of new things to think about, you just dont get that anywhere else at the moment.

jed
it's all good isnt it, lots of new info all the time

Awesome right now on here for me :mrgreen:

jed